The Rule You Didn’t Write: Finding Silent Forwarding in Microsoft 365 and Google Workspace
Most email compromises do not announce themselves with a locked screen or a ransom note. They leave something much duller behind: a rule. It might be called “.”, “RSS”, “Accounts” or “Admin”. It sits server-side, quietly copying selected messages to an outside address. No one sees it in the CC line. No one gets a notification. The inbox looks normal because, for the person using it, it is normal.
That is the invisible CC problem. An attacker who gets into a mailbox for ten minutes can create a rule that keeps feeding them information for months. For a UK small business, the useful question is not “could this happen to us?” It is “who would notice if it already had?”
The rule that looks like housekeeping
Take a scenario we see in different shapes: a 28-person joinery in Nottingham. The finance manager’s mailbox is compromised after a password reuse slip. The attacker does not send a dramatic email to every customer. They create an inbox rule: any message containing “invoice”, “statement” or “remittance” gets forwarded to a free webmail address and marked as read. They also add a second rule that moves messages from the managing director into a subfolder called “Archive”.
The joinery only spots it when a supplier rings to ask why an invoice has not been paid. The supplier’s email was in the finance manager’s inbox, but the reply chain had been copied elsewhere. The attacker had been reading the thread and timing a fake bank-details change. The rule was not clever. It was just unseen.
This is why mailbox rules deserve a place in your cyber hygiene routine alongside MFA and backup tests. They are small, persistent and easy to forget.
Forwarding vs inbox rules: the difference matters
People use the words “forwarding” and “rules” interchangeably. In Microsoft 365 and Google Workspace they are related, but not the same thing.
Auto-forwarding is usually a single mailbox setting. It says: send incoming mail to another address. It is blunt. In Microsoft 365 you can see it in the mailbox’s mail flow settings. In Gmail it sits under Forwarding and POP/IMAP. If it is switched on and you did not ask for it, treat it as suspicious.
Inbox rules are conditional. They can forward, redirect, delete, move or mark messages as read based on who sent them, what words they contain or whether they have attachments. Attackers like rules because they can be selective. A rule that forwards only messages from your bank, your biggest client or anyone using the word “payment” is harder to notice than a blanket forward.
There is also a subtle difference between forward and redirect. A forward usually shows the original sender in the body or headers. A redirect can make the message look as though it came straight from the original sender. That makes a reply from the wrong person even harder to spot.
A 20-minute first pass in Microsoft 365
For a small tenant, a first pass can take about 20 minutes if you have admin rights and know where to look. Start with the mailboxes that would cause the most damage: finance, owner, sales, office manager and anyone who approves payments.
- Sign in to the Exchange admin centre.
- Go to Recipients > Mailboxes and open the high-risk mailbox.
- Under Mailbox features, check Mail flow > Email forwarding. Remove any address you cannot explain.
- Check inbox rules. The quickest way is Outlook on the web for that user, but for a whole tenant ask your IT provider to run a PowerShell report. The command usually looks like:
Get-Mailbox | Get-InboxRule | Where-Object { $_.ForwardTo -or $_.RedirectTo -or $_.ForwardAsAttachmentTo }. - Review the output for rules that forward or redirect to external addresses, or rules with vague names that no one recognises.
- In Mail flow > Remote domains, open the default domain and clear “Allow automatic forwarding” unless you have a documented reason to keep it.
If PowerShell makes you twitch, that is fine. The important part is not the command. It is the habit of looking.
The Google Workspace version
Google’s admin console works differently, but the logic is the same. In the Admin console, go to Apps > Google Workspace > Gmail > Compliance > Auto-forwarding. Decide whether users should be able to forward mail to external addresses at all. Many SMEs can safely restrict this to a named group or switch it off.
Then check user-level settings. In Gmail, open Settings > Forwarding and POP/IMAP, and Settings > Filters and Blocked Addresses. Look for filters that forward to an outside address, delete messages or mark them as read. A filter called “stuff” with a forwarding address is rarely a business requirement.
For a bulk view across many users, you will need the Gmail API, Apps Script or a third-party tool. The Alert centre can also show changes to forwarding settings, so make sure admin alerts are switched on and going to a monitored inbox rather than a shared mailbox nobody opens.
The controls that make the next compromise less useful
Finding a rogue rule is only half the job. The other half is making sure the next one is harder to create and easier to spot.
- Turn on admin alerts for forwarding changes, new inbox rules and suspicious sign-ins. Send them to two people, not one.
- Block external auto-forwarding by default unless a specific role needs it. Document the exceptions.
- Review mailbox rules quarterly. Put it in the same calendar block as your backup restore test.
- Use two reviewers. An operations lead and a finance lead should sign off the report, with your IT provider supplying the evidence.
- Reset sessions and passwords if you find anything unexplained. A rule can survive a password change, so remove it first and then reset.
Who checks, and when?
The worst answer is “whoever set up the tenant”. Mailbox rules are not a one-off setup task. They are a small but regular check that belongs with your other finance and cyber controls. A quarterly review is enough for most UK SMEs, provided it actually happens and someone keeps a note of what was found.
At Intercept IT, we would rather you spend 20 minutes this month than discover a silent forwarding rule six months into a client relationship. The rule you didn’t write is the one worth looking for.