Intercept IT All articles
Cybersecurity

The Auto-Reply That Hands Over the Org Chart

Intercept IT
The Auto-Reply That Hands Over the Org Chart

Photo: Geleparaplu, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

It is mid-November, which in most UK SMEs means the leave requests are stacking up. Half term is done, the Christmas shutdown rota is being argued over, and someone in the office has just set an out-of-office that reads like a small press release.

That little auto-reply is one of the few pieces of your business that gets sent to strangers, automatically, without anyone checking it first. And unlike a marketing email, nobody has ever given it a second thought.

What your auto-reply is actually broadcasting

Read your current one back as though you were a fraudster who has never met you. A fairly ordinary example might say:

'I'm out of the office until Monday 24 November with limited access to email. For anything urgent, please contact Sarah Chen in finance on sarah.chen@ or 07700 900123. I'll be checking Xero sporadically.'

That is four separate gifts. It tells the sender you are unreachable for a defined window. It names a colleague, their department and their direct line. It hands over a mobile number that probably is not published anywhere. And it leaks an internal system name, which is exactly the sort of detail that makes a follow-up email feel genuine.

None of it is reckless. It is written by someone trying to be helpful, which is why it survives year after year.

Why the scammers like the gap

An out-of-office is a free organisational map, and it scales. Send one bland enquiry to fifty addresses scraped from a website or a trade directory and you will collect twenty replies, each one naming a cover contact, a return date and a mobile number. Nobody has to break into anything.

The follow-up usually writes itself. A message arrives for 'Sarah Chen in finance' from someone claiming to be the person who is away, apologising for bothering her while on leave, and asking for a small favour: a bank detail confirmation, a payment run brought forward, a supplier's new account details checked. The tone is right, the context is right, and the timing is perfect because the real person is on a beach in Lanzarote and cannot contradict any of it.

There is a second, quieter version. The scammer writes to a client of the away person instead, pretending to be the cover contact, and asks for a document or a payment. The client has never spoken to this person before, but the name was in the auto-reply, so it feels legitimate.

Either way, the entry point was not a clever hack. It was a helpful sentence.

The five-line rewrite

You do not need to be secretive. You need to be unhelpful to the wrong people and perfectly helpful to the right ones. Something like this does the job:

  1. Thanks for your email. I am away from the office until [date] and will not be checking messages.
  2. For anything urgent, please contact the office on [main switchboard number] or email [team inbox] and a colleague will pick it up.
  3. Please do not send changes to payment or bank details by email. We will always confirm those by phone.
  4. I will reply properly when I am back.

Four lines, in fact. Keep it that short.

Notice what is missing: no colleague's name, no personal mobile, no mention of which systems you can and cannot reach, and no detail about where you are or why. 'Away from the office' covers a hospital appointment and a fortnight in Portugal equally well.

So when should you name a colleague?

Sometimes you genuinely cannot avoid it, particularly for account managers and sales roles where clients will simply ring the named person anyway. A workable rule for a UK small business is this: name someone only when all three of the following are true.

If the request is financial or sensitive, route it to the office. Money changes hands through a process, not through a person's inbox, and a named individual is much easier to impersonate convincingly than a switchboard.

The same logic applies to your voicemail greeting. 'Hi, you've reached Priya, I'm on leave until the 24th, try Dev on 07700...' is the audio version of the same mistake.

A ten-minute check before the next break

Do this once, before the Christmas shutdown rather than the morning everyone leaves.

The habit underneath it

Treat the auto-reply as public content, because it is. It goes out unattended to anyone who happens to write to you, and the version an attacker sees is the one you wrote in a hurry on the way to catch a train.

If you want one thing to take away from this: your out-of-office should tell people how to get help, not who is where. The switchboard is boring. Boring is the point.

Set a reminder for the first week of December, before the office empties, and rewrite it once. It takes less time than the average phone call about a suspicious invoice.

All Articles

Related Articles

Who Still Has the Keys? The Leavers' Login Audit Your SME Probably Skipped

Who Still Has the Keys? The Leavers' Login Audit Your SME Probably Skipped

The Last-Minute Account Change: How Two Phone Calls Can Stop Invoice Fraud

The Last-Minute Account Change: How Two Phone Calls Can Stop Invoice Fraud

Proof of Life: The 30-Minute Restore Test That Tells You Whether Your Backup Is Real

Proof of Life: The 30-Minute Restore Test That Tells You Whether Your Backup Is Real